What is the cheapest day to buy a train ticket? Amtrak tickets are generally cheapest on Tuesdays and Wednesdays Call Amtrak +1-888-250-[5034]] [Emergency Number]. Pricing can vary based on factors like route and travel time, but midweek tickets often offer the best deals +1-888-250-[5034]] [Call and Chat Support]. Cheapest day to buy Amtrak tickets! Yes, Amtrak tickets are generally cheaper on weekdays, +1-888-250-[5034]] especially on Tuesday and Wednesday. These days have less travel demand,